The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Ameche’s Overtime Touchdown Gives Baltimore the Championship
Alan Ameche plunged one yard for an overtime touchdown yesterday, giving Baltimore a 23–17 victory over the New York Giants and its first National Football League championship at Yankee Stadium.
NEW YORK, Dec. 29.—Alan Ameche plunged one yard for an overtime touchdown yesterday, giving Baltimore a 23–17 victory over the New York Giants and its first National Football League championship at Yankee Stadium. The Colts needed a late tying field goal in regulation before Johnny Unitas directed the decisive drive in the extra period.
Steve Myhra’s short kick brought Baltimore level in the closing seconds after New York had recovered from a 14–3 halftime deficit. The Giants received the overtime kickoff but could not score. Unitas then moved the Colts downfield, with Raymond Berry again providing a dependable receiving target, until Ameche carried the ball across the goal line.
Berry finished with twelve receptions for 178 yards. Unitas passed for 349 yards, sustaining Baltimore’s challenge through a game marked by turnovers and reversals of momentum. The championship had never previously required sudden-death overtime. Yesterday afternoon the rule left no shared title and no opportunity for an answering possession: Ameche’s touchdown ended the contest and made Baltimore champion.
Sources & further reading
- Pro Football Hall of Fame — 1958 chronology — Pro Football Hall of Fame.
- NFL Championship — historical game record — Wikipedia contributors.

