The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Deputies Remove Families as Ravine Homes Fall
A forcible eviction on Malvina Street brings the long dispute over Chavez Ravine from council chambers into the homes of its remaining residents.

Sheriff’s deputies carry Aurora Vargas from the Aréchiga family home during the Chavez Ravine evictions in May 1959. The eviction occurred May 8; UCLA dates this record May 9. Photograph: Los Angeles Times Photographic Archive / UCLA Library Special Collections. Copyright The Regents of the University of California. CC BY 4.0. Image source · CC BY 4.0. Web-sized reproduction; no content alteration. Full negative border retained where present.
LOS ANGELES, May 10. Sheriff’s deputies removed members of the Aréchiga family from their Chavez Ravine home Friday, and the house was demolished. The family returned to the site that evening with a tent and supporters. Councilman Edward Roybal visited their encampment.
The removal carries a history that cannot be reduced to the moment a deputy reached a door. Palo Verde, La Loma and Bishop were acquired for the proposed Elysian Park Heights public-housing development. That project was abandoned. The land is now intended for a stadium and associated recreation facilities.
The city’s arrangement with the Dodgers received voter approval in last year’s referendum. The California Supreme Court’s January opinion records the proposed exchange of property and the club’s stadium obligations. A public vote and a legal proceeding establish parts of the municipal record. They do not establish that a displaced household consented to losing its home.
The distinction is visible in the family’s return. Possession of a parcel can change while the people removed from it continue to regard it as their place. A tent beside a demolished house makes that disagreement harder to overlook than a line on a redevelopment map.
The earlier housing purpose matters for the same reason. Residents were asked to yield land for one undertaking and have watched another take its place. The abandonment of the first plan did not reconstruct the houses already lost or bring a dispersed neighborhood back together.
The surviving record must include tenants and children as well as titleholders. A neighborhood is made through repeated use: a route to school, relatives within walking distance and nearby people upon whom a family can rely. Compensation for land, where offered, does not automatically reproduce those arrangements.
The immediate confrontation has ended with a house gone and its former occupants still nearby. Municipal officers may enter the operation as property cleared. The family’s encampment supplies another entry: resistance continuing after the machinery has done its work. Whatever is built in the ravine will occupy ground whose recent history includes both records.
Sources & further reading
- Public Purpose and Private Gain in the Chavez Ravine— UCLA Library, Divided Development exhibit; no individual byline displayed; February 4, 2021.
- Queen of Elysian Heights— Los Angeles Conservancy; Undated preservation record; accessed November 9, 2026.
- City of Los Angeles v. Superior Court, 51 Cal. 2d 423— Chief Justice Phil S. Gibson, Supreme Court of California; January 13, 1959.

