The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Religious-Freedom Law Restores a Stricter Test for Government Burdens
President Clinton signs legislation requiring a compelling justification and the least restrictive means when religious exercise is substantially burdened.
WASHINGTON, Nov. 17 — President Clinton signed the Religious Freedom Restoration Act yesterday, establishing a statutory test for government action that substantially burdens a person’s exercise of religion.
Under the act, the government must demonstrate a compelling interest and use the least restrictive means of furthering it when the statute’s substantial-burden requirement is met. The rule is directed even at measures that apply generally rather than expressly singling out a faith.
Congress acted after the Supreme Court’s 1990 decision in Employment Division v. Smith. The new law seeks to restore a stronger protection through legislation; it does not erase the Court’s constitutional opinion or settle every future dispute about religious exercise.
At the signing, Clinton presented the measure as a protection for Americans across religious traditions. The text allows a person whose religious exercise has been burdened to raise the act in a judicial proceeding and seek appropriate relief.
The difficult cases will turn on the actual burden, the government’s purpose and the alternatives available to it. Yesterday’s signing gives those disputes a demanding legal standard. It does not mean that a religious claim automatically defeats every public requirement, or that a general public rule can be enforced without examining its effect.
Sources & further reading
Related Herald reporting
- Congress Recognizes a Federal Duty to Protect Native Religious Practice — Katherine “Kate” Romero, 1978-08-13.


Join the conversation