The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
A Public Appeal Deserves Careful Editing
An editorial on verifying public-safety appeals after the FBI releases photographs in the Boston bombing investigation.
Editorial
The FBI today released photographs and video of two suspects in the Boston Marathon bombing investigation and asked the public to help identify them. Special Agent in Charge Richard DesLauriers also warned against using other photographs for that purpose and told people to leave any approach or apprehension to law enforcement.
Those limits belong beside the appeal every time it is published. A news organization can help readers recognize the material investigators have released, understand the request and find the appropriate way to supply information. It must also make clear what the photographs establish and what investigators are still trying to learn.
A face in a crowd is a person’s identity before it becomes a theory on a message board. Editors should require a verifiable basis before attaching a name to an accusation. A resemblance suggested by an unknown contributor is a lead to examine privately; circulation gives it consequences that examination alone does not.
An official statement also requires attribution. Readers should know which agency issued it and when. If its instructions change, the update should be prominent enough to reach someone who saw the earlier version. A page carrying urgent information ought to make its latest verified status easy to find.
The work belongs across the newsroom. The reporter checks the source of the claim. The editor tests whether the evidence supports the proposed wording. The producer checks that the photograph, caption and introductory text all refer to the same verified account. A hurried transmission should not sever those connections.
Photographs of victims and bystanders require separate judgment. Public interest in an investigation is not a general invitation to expose every frightened or injured person to repeated display. A useful image should have a clear reporting purpose, a dependable identification and a caption that respects the limits of the evidence.
The demand for speed is real. So is the damage an unsupported identification can cause. A public-safety appeal should leave a reader better informed about the verified request and its boundaries. Careful editing is part of the assistance a newspaper owes the public in an emergency.
Referenced images: FBI’s archived April 18, 2013 public appeal and released-image context.
Sources & further reading
- Remarks of Special Agent in Charge Richard DesLauriers at Press Conference on Bombing Investigation — Richard DesLauriers; FBI Boston; April 18, 2013.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation