The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Bunker Hill’s New Plan Leaves an Old Housing Question
The adopted redevelopment plan encompasses 133 acres. Its consequences must also be measured in the rooms and daily arrangements on which existing residents depend.
LOS ANGELES — The city’s March 31 adoption of the Bunker Hill redevelopment project has placed a new official future over a district that still serves an immediate purpose as a place to live. Its 133 acres contain more than buildings marked for change. They contain the inexpensive rooms on which pensioners and low-income workers organize their days.
The project’s boundaries describe a piece of downtown between First Street, Hill Street, Fifth Street and the Harbor Freeway. Within that outline, former large residences have been divided into lodgings, alongside rooming houses and residential hotels. The resulting neighborhood is difficult to understand through a single word such as blight.
A crowded or deteriorated building can be a serious housing problem. It can simultaneously supply a room at a price its occupant can pay. Removing the structure addresses one condition while creating another. Redevelopment’s housing account must follow both.
The hill’s slopes make the local arrangement particularly distinct. Angels Flight connects Hill and Olive streets beside Third Street, giving a short railway journey an everyday use in a steep neighborhood. For a resident, proximity to downtown shops and services is part of the value of a room. A replacement address should be examined with those distances in view.
The Community Redevelopment Agency’s case for transformation rests in part on the physical conditions it has documented. Photographer Leonard Nadel’s work for the agency during the first half of the decade records streets, interiors and residents. Such evidence can show neglected housing. It can also preserve information about the lives that an official plan may otherwise reduce to occupancy totals.
The practical questions are more exacting than a comparison of old and new skylines. How many low-cost rooms will be lost? What can their occupants afford elsewhere? Will assistance be available before a household has to move? Counting cleared parcels will not answer any of these questions.
There is also a difference between the value assigned to a property and the usefulness of a neighborhood to a tenant. A resident may have little claim on the investment that rises where a rooming house stood, while bearing the full inconvenience of finding another room. The city’s housing report should make that uneven distribution visible.
Bunker Hill is now the subject of an adopted plan. Its residents remain people who must find a bed tomorrow night, buy food and reach the places they depend upon. Following redevelopment responsibly means keeping that ordinary timetable beside the much longer timetable of urban transformation.
Sources & further reading
Related Herald reporting
- John Fante’s Bunker Hill Survives Between Covers — Joseph Ashford, 1980-11-23.
- Angels Flight Is Dismantled After Its Last Sunday Runs — Charles Benton, 1969-05-20.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation