The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Calvert Cliffs ruling orders nuclear licensing to confront environmental costs
A federal appeals court rejects the Atomic Energy Commission’s environmental procedures and sends them back for further rulemaking.
A federal appeals court has ruled that the Atomic Energy Commission's procedures fail to satisfy the National Environmental Policy Act. The July 23 decision in the Calvert Cliffs case requires the commission to take environmental consequences seriously within its own licensing process.
Writing for the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Judge J. Skelly Wright rejected the view that NEPA left the agency free to treat environmental review as a limited addition to its established work. The court remanded the cases for further rulemaking.
The decision reaches beyond a dispute over one Maryland power station. It concerns how a federal agency weighs environmental damage against the benefits of an activity it is asked to approve. Under the court's reasoning, collecting a statement is insufficient if the decision-making process avoids the questions that statement raises.
That does not mean the court has prohibited nuclear power or required environmental concerns to prevail in every case. It means officials must exercise their discretion through a procedure that genuinely considers those concerns. The distinction matters to utilities planning plants and to communities seeking a fair hearing about water, land and other effects.
The ruling creates a public record against which decisions can be judged. Applicants must explain their projects; regulators must account for the choices they make. The costs of environmental review will enter an already demanding construction process, but those costs cannot be assessed honestly without also considering the damage that an inadequate review might leave to others. Nuclear licensing has been told to show its work.
Sources & further reading
- Calvert Cliffs’ Coordinating Committee, Inc. v. United States Atomic Energy Commission, 449 F.2d 1109 — Judge J. Skelly Wright, U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit; reproduced by OpenJurist; July 23, 1971.
- National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, Public Law 91-190 — 91st U.S. Congress; January 1, 1970.
Related Herald reporting
- California Adds Environmental Review to Public Decisions — Samuel Ellis, 1970-09-19.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation