The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Every Disaster Figure Needs Its Date and Definition
An editorial on distinguishing estimates, observations and revised counts in earthquake reporting.
Editorial
A year after the January 17 Northridge earthquake, the record of the disaster still offers a useful lesson in the way a newspaper handles numbers. The National Institute of Standards and Technology’s report last May cited estimates of people temporarily or permanently displaced ranging from 80,000 to 125,000. The stated range and the people being counted are both part of the information.
A news desk should preserve those qualifications. A report about people displaced from damaged homes describes a different quantity from a count of destroyed dwellings, occupied apartments or applications for assistance. These figures may all be useful. Their labels allow the reader to understand what each can establish.
Disaster reporting begins under exceptional pressure. Conditions change, communications fail and several agencies may examine different parts of the same problem. A responsible account should say who supplied a figure, when it was supplied and whether it is an observation, an estimate or an administrative count. Those few words give readers a way to compare the next report with the first.
When a figure changes, the follow-up should explain the change. A larger total may reflect additional inspection, a wider area or a revised definition. A smaller one may result from removing duplicate reports. Each possibility calls for inquiry. The difference alone tells us too little to assign blame or announce improvement.
Headlines and charts require the same discipline as paragraphs. A range should remain a range. A preliminary tally should carry its preliminary character into the display. An attractive single number can be less informative than a modest account of what remains uncertain.
Public agencies should help by issuing dated statements with stable definitions and a clear indication of what has been revised. Newspapers should retain enough of that record to explain their own updates. The aim is a sequence readers can follow from the first emergency account to the more considered assessment.
Preparedness includes knowing how to communicate the limits of knowledge. The next emergency will again bring an urgent demand for totals. Our answer should give the strongest information available, accompanied by the date, source and meaning that make it useful.
Sources & further reading
- 1994 Northridge Earthquake: Performance of Structures, Lifelines and Fire Protection Systems, NIST Special Publication 862 — Nicholas J. Carino, R.M. Chung, Hai S. Lew, A.W. Taylor and William D. Walton; National Institute of Standards and Technology; May 1994.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation