The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Give the Web Reader the Whole Argument
An editorial on careful editing and access to complete public documents after the Supreme Court’s Internet speech decision.
Editorial
The Supreme Court yesterday struck down the challenged Internet indecency restrictions in Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union. The decision protects a broad field of expression. It should also prompt newspapers entering that field to consider how faithfully they will carry a complicated public argument.
A screen can give a reader a headline, a short account and a route to the underlying document. That combination can improve understanding. It can also produce the appearance of completeness while leaving out the qualifications on which the decision depends. The editor remains responsible for the journey from the document to the reader.
In this case, a declaration that the Court has approved every form of expression on the Internet would go beyond the ruling. The majority addressed particular restrictions and their breadth under the First Amendment. Justice O’Connor, joined by Chief Justice Rehnquist, wrote separately, concurring in the judgment in part and dissenting in part. A useful account should make room for that distinction.
Electronic production gives corrections and supplementary material a new convenience. The copy desk should use it deliberately. Where a summary is shortened, preserve the passage that identifies what was decided. Where a legal term carries a narrower meaning than its everyday counterpart, explain it before a brisk headline enlarges it.
A link to the opinion can serve readers who want the entire argument. Its presence should strengthen the summary by making the editing open to inspection. Readers should be able to see which passages support the account and where the paper has offered an interpretation of its own.
The same care belongs in the headline, the introductory sentence and any index entry. A careful qualification buried several paragraphs below an overconfident heading cannot do all the work of accuracy. Each part of the presentation should remain true when encountered on its own.
The Court has considered the government’s power over a new means of communication. Newspapers must consider the quality of the communication they supply. Our useful contribution is an intelligible account, a visible distinction between holding and comment, and a dependable route to the full record.
Sources & further reading
- Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union, No. 96-511: opinion of the Court — Justice John Paul Stevens; Supreme Court of the United States; primary opinion reproduced by Cornell LII; June 26, 1997.
- Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union: opinion concurring in the judgment in part and dissenting in part — Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, joined by Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist; Supreme Court of the United States; June 26, 1997.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation