The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Scott’s Absent Oscar Leaves a Question About the Contest Itself
George C. Scott wins for Patton after rejecting the Academy’s competitive ritual; his absence distinguishes the 43rd awards.
HOLLYWOOD, April 16.—The Academy has named George C. Scott best actor for Patton despite his refusal to take part in its contest. His absence gave the 43rd Academy Awards an awkward distinction: the principal male performance was honored without the performer’s consent to the ceremony.
Frank McCarthy, the picture’s producer, appeared for Scott. Patton also received the picture and directing awards, making the actor’s objection a conspicuous interruption in an otherwise triumphant evening for the production.
Scott’s position is directed at the practice of setting performances against one another for prizes. The award records the voters’ judgment; it cannot compel the actor to endorse the method by which that judgment is advertised.
The disagreement does not change the result. Scott remains the winner announced by the Academy. It does, however, prevent the usual easy equation between winning an Oscar and wanting one. Hollywood’s most familiar ceremony has encountered a player unwilling to play his assigned part.
Sources & further reading
Related Herald reporting
- Patton Takes Seven Oscars; Scott Wins Despite His Refusal — Francis Holloway, 1971-04-16.
- Midnight Cowboy Takes Picture, Direction and Screenplay Oscars — Francis Holloway, 1970-04-08.
- The French Connection Wins Five at the 44th Oscars — Denise Whitfield, 1972-04-11.




Join the conversation