The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Redgrave and Chayefsky Bring a Political Argument to the 50th Oscars
The supporting-actress acceptance for Julia and a reply from Paddy Chayefsky divide the Academy stage over political speeches.
LOS ANGELES, April 5.—Vanessa Redgrave’s supporting-actress award for Julia has become entangled with an argument over the Middle East and over the use of an Oscar acceptance speech for political purposes.
At Monday’s 50th Academy Awards, Redgrave condemned demonstrators who had campaigned against her. Her support for the Palestinian cause had drawn protests; her response from the stage drew both applause and disapproval.
Paddy Chayefsky, appearing later as a presenter, rebuked the introduction of personal political positions into the awards program. His intervention supplied a second political moment in the course of objecting to the first.
The distinction between Redgrave’s performance and her public commitments has proved difficult to maintain around the ceremony. The Academy’s vote honored her acting in Julia. The demonstrations and the exchange at the microphone concerned issues well beyond that performance.
The immediate result is a prize whose professional meaning remains clear, accompanied by a public quarrel which no vote in an acting category could settle.
Sources & further reading
- Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences — The 50th Academy Awards — official winners and ceremony record
- Mideast conflict at Oscar ceremonies — Jewish Telegraphic Agency; April 5, 1978.
Related Herald reporting
- Annie Hall Takes Picture and Direction at the 50th Oscars — Karen Westbrook, 1978-04-04.
- Rocky Wins Picture; Network Takes Three Acting Oscars — Karen Westbrook, 1977-03-29.
- The Deer Hunter Wins Five at the 51st Academy Awards — Karen Westbrook, 1979-04-10.


Join the conversation