The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Kazan’s Honorary Oscar Reopens Hollywood’s Blacklist Argument
The 71st awards honor Elia Kazan’s filmmaking amid objections to his naming of former associates before HUAC.
LOS ANGELES, March 22.—The Academy’s honorary award to Elia Kazan last night brought Hollywood’s blacklist argument back to the center of its most public ceremony. The 71st Oscars honored a director whose artistic reputation and political conduct remain subjects of sharply different judgments.
Kazan’s work includes A Streetcar Named Desire and On the Waterfront. The objection to honoring him concerns his 1952 testimony before the House Committee on Un-American Activities, when he named former Communist associates.
To supporters of the award, a lifetime honor recognizes an exceptional contribution to motion pictures. To opponents, the presentation risks lending the Academy’s prestige to conduct associated with lost livelihoods and professional exclusion.
Those positions cannot be reconciled simply by repeating the titles of his films. Nor does the argument require denying that the films mattered. It concerns what an institution chooses to celebrate when it honors a career in the presence of the people who lived through its consequences.
The statuette closes the Academy’s decision. It leaves the larger judgment open.
Sources & further reading
- Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences — The 71st Academy Awards — official winners and ceremony record
- Elia Kazan — career, HUAC testimony and honorary Oscar dispute — PBS American Masters; biographical reference.
- Honorary Academy Awards register — Elia Kazan, 71st awards — Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences; official register.
Related Herald reporting
- Shakespeare in Love Wins Seven; Spielberg Takes Directing Prize — Karen Westbrook, 1999-03-22.
- Titanic Ties the Eleven-Oscar Record at the 70th Academy Awards — Karen Westbrook, 1998-03-24.
- American Beauty Wins Five at the 72nd Oscars — Karen Westbrook, 2000-03-27.


Join the conversation