The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Academy Revokes Song Nomination After Composer’s Campaign Email
Alone Yet Not Alone leaves the 86th Oscars ballot after the Academy finds improper promotion by Bruce Broughton.
LOS ANGELES, Jan. 30 — The Academy has withdrawn the original-song nomination for Alone Yet Not Alone, saying composer Bruce Broughton’s email campaign created an appearance of unfair advantage in the voting for the 86th Oscars.
Broughton, a former Academy governor and current member of the music branch’s executive committee, contacted branch members during the nominations period to draw attention to the submission. The board concluded that the promotion conflicted with the Academy’s campaign regulations.
The song carried music by Broughton and lyrics by Dennis Spiegel. Its removal will leave four nominees; the Academy says it will not name a replacement.
The decision concerns the conduct of the campaign rather than a new artistic judgment about the song. It also makes a distinction between ordinary publicity and a personal appeal carrying the standing of an Academy officeholder.
The awards are scheduled for March 2. For the remaining song contenders, the ballot is smaller; for campaigners across the industry, the board’s action supplies a warning about how a submission is promoted.
Sources & further reading
- Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences — The 86th Academy Awards — official winners and ceremony record
- Academy rescinds original-song nomination for Alone Yet Not Alone — Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences; January 29, 2014.
Related Herald reporting
- 12 Years a Slave Wins Picture; Gravity Takes Seven Oscars — Camille Jackson, 2014-03-03.
- Argo Wins Picture; Life of Pi Collects Four Oscars — Camille Jackson, 2013-02-25.
- Birdman Wins Four at the 87th Academy Awards — Camille Jackson, 2015-02-23.





Join the conversation