The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Academy Removes Envelope Accountants From Future Oscar Shows
The two accountants involved in the 89th Oscars’ final-envelope failure will not return to the show.

LOS ANGELES, March 2 — The two PricewaterhouseCoopers accountants involved in the best-picture envelope failure will not return to work the Oscar show, the Academy says, as it examines the breakdown at the 89th awards.
Brian Cullinan handed presenters the wrong envelope, producing the announcement of La La Land before Moonlight was correctly identified as the winner. Cullinan and Martha Ruiz were the accountants stationed at the ceremony.
The decision concerns the show’s personnel. It does not change the winning picture or turn the mistaken announcement into a dispute about the ballot. Moonlight’s Oscar remains the result the Academy was meant to announce.
Removing the accountants answers one immediate question about responsibility. The larger operational question is how the presentation can prevent a wrong handoff, recognize an error promptly and correct it before an acceptance proceeds.
The spectacle of one group of filmmakers surrendering the stage to another has made the backstage procedure unusually public. The Academy now has to restore confidence in a system whose purpose is to make the final announcement appear simple.
Sources & further reading
Related Herald reporting
- Moonlight Wins Picture After the 89th Oscars’ Corrected Announcement — Camille Jackson, 2017-02-27.
- Wrong Envelope Gives Moonlight’s Oscar Moment to La La Land First — Camille Jackson, 2017-02-27.
- Spotlight Wins Picture; The Revenant and Mad Max Share Major Honors — Camille Jackson, 2016-02-29.
- The Shape of Water Wins Four at the 90th Academy Awards — Camille Jackson, 2018-03-05.




Join the conversation