The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Psychology review traces incarceration’s effects through family silence and later generations
Researchers examine how wartime losses, family communication and public redress shaped experiences after confinement, while recognizing differences among families.
A new review in the January issue of American Psychologist examines how the wartime incarceration of Japanese Americans continued to affect families long after release. The authors bring together research on survivors, their children and grandchildren, including the place of family silence and public redress in those experiences.
Donna K. Nagata and Kaidi Wu of the University of Michigan and Jacqueline H. J. Kim of UCLA describe a history with psychological, economic and social consequences. Their article reviews earlier research. Its account includes hardship and resilience, with different responses across people and generations.
Communication has been an empirical subject as well as a theme in personal accounts. A 2003 study by Nagata and Wendy J. Y. Cheng surveyed 450 second-generation Japanese American former incarcerees, known as Nisei, about communications with their children born after the war. The project treated what parents said, and what they did not say, as part of the family experience of a racial injustice.
Research on redress also found differences. A 2002 study by Nagata and Yuzuru J. Takeshita asked former incarcerees about eight areas of personal impact after compensation. Respondents reported the strongest effect on faith in government and the weakest on physical suffering. Responses varied with factors including age and gender. An apology’s meaning could therefore differ from its capacity to relieve a particular injury.
The new review describes family histories in which parents avoided discussing confinement in hopes of shielding children from its pain. It also considers the effects of lost property and livelihoods, pressure to assimilate, and gaps in knowledge about Japanese language and culture. Such consequences can enter a child’s life without that child having lived behind a camp fence.
The evidence calls for care in drawing conclusions. Much of the research uses retrospective surveys and personal accounts. Associations between communication, emotion and family closeness do not establish one inevitable outcome for every household. A respondent’s experience of anger, pride or mistrust cannot simply be assigned to another person with a similar ancestry.
The result is a record of several ways the past can remain present: in a conversation delayed, an opportunity lost, a public acknowledgment received or a family member’s effort to learn what happened.
Sources & further reading
- The Japanese American Wartime Incarceration: Examining the Scope of Racial Trauma — Donna K. Nagata, Jacqueline H. J. Kim and Kaidi Wu; American Psychologist 74(1), 36–48 (2019-01).
- Intergenerational communication of race-related trauma by Japanese American former internees — Donna K. Nagata and Wendy J. Y. Cheng; American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 73(3), 266–278 (2003-07).
- Psychological reactions to redress: diversity among Japanese Americans interned during World War II — Donna K. Nagata and Yuzuru J. Takeshita; Cultural Diversity & Ethnic Minority Psychology 8(1), 41–59 (2002-02).
Related Herald reporting
- Federal commission urges apology and $20,000 payments for wartime incarceration — Joan Mercer, 1983-06-17.
- Reagan signs apology and $20,000 redress law for Japanese American survivors — Richard Hale, 1988-08-11.
- First redress checks reach nine survivors, including a 107-year-old Angeleno — Richard Hale, 1990-10-12.
- California Assembly apologizes for its role in Japanese American incarceration — Amanda Rhodes, 2020-02-21.
- Book of incarceration names begins national journey, with Manzanar visit planned — Amanda Rhodes, 2025-02-22.
- Manzanar children’s home study puts survivor and descendant voices into preservation plans — Amanda Rhodes, 2026-10-01.
- New redress rule includes some wartime-born children excluded from the family home — Stephen Evers, 1997-05-28.
- Judge’s written opinion identifies withheld evidence behind Korematsu conviction — Joan Mercer, 1984-04-20.
- New federal law opens property-loss claims for Japanese American evacuation — Samuel Voss, 1948-07-03.
- War Relocation Authority ends; its records and unfinished affairs pass to Interior — William Keane, 1946-12-31.
- Manzanar closes as former residents face the difficult work of return — William Keane, 1945-11-22.
- Court upholds exclusion conviction but bars detention of a citizen conceded loyal — Samuel Voss, 1944-12-19.
- Jerome closes, but transfers carry its families to other camps — William Keane, 1944-07-01.
- Tule Lake segregation policy sends families into another round of removal — William Keane, 1943-10-16.
- Supreme Court sustains Japanese American curfew convictions; Yasui case returned for sentence — Samuel Voss, 1943-06-22.
- Manzanar’s first newspaper reports 3,302 people as removal reshapes family life — William Keane, 1942-04-12.
- Roosevelt gives military broad authority to exclude civilians from designated areas — Samuel Voss, 1942-02-25.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation