The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
War Authority Requires Continuing Public Scrutiny
An editorial urging Congress to sustain oversight after authorizing force against those responsible for the September 11 attacks.
Editorial
President Bush yesterday approved Congress’s authorization to use force against those responsible for the September 11 attacks and those who harbored them. The resolution leaves the President substantial responsibility for identifying the nations, organizations and persons within its terms. Congress must remain answerable for the authority it has granted.
The country is entitled to an effective defense and to an account of how that defense is conducted. Those purposes belong together. Citizens asked to support military action should be told its objective, the grounds on which responsibility is assigned, and the measures by which the government will judge its progress.
Certain operational information must remain protected while lives depend on it. That necessity should be explained with care. It should not become a general exemption for policy, expenditure or legal reasoning. Officials can describe the purpose of an operation and the basis for their authority without publishing every detail of its execution.
The resolution expressly preserves the other requirements of the War Powers Resolution. Congress should use its continuing responsibilities: seek reports, examine expenditure, question the evidence offered for major decisions and make its own judgments public wherever security permits. Voting for an authorization is the beginning of that work.
The wording also gives newspapers a responsibility to be exact. The authorization is tied to the attacks of September 11. Reports should distinguish an allegation of responsibility, an official determination and the evidence disclosed to support it. A common enemy cannot be established by the repetition of an uncertain identification.
For Southern Californians, the stakes will be practical as well as constitutional. Families asked to bear military service and communities asked to accept new burdens deserve explanations they can understand. Public discussion should leave room for questions about the scope and conduct of the response, even among citizens united in condemning the attacks.
No one can now promise the duration or final cost of the undertaking. That uncertainty strengthens the case for regular, serious review. The President should act within the authority granted, Congress should oversee its use, and the press should keep the public able to judge both.
Sources & further reading
- Authorization for Use of Military Force, Public Law 107-40 — United States Congress; approved by President George W. Bush; September 18, 2001.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation