The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
When the P Car Becomes the 26, the Passenger Still Has a Claim
The last streetcar conversions should be judged by the journeys they preserve, including those of riders who must learn a new route number to make the same daily trip.
EDITORIAL — Los Angeles has concluded another argument about its future with a change of vehicles. On March 31, the Metropolitan Transit Authority replaced its five remaining rail lines and two trolley-coach lines with motor buses. The arrival of new SilverLiner coaches has been celebrated. The passenger’s accounting should begin now.
The alterations are precise enough to write on a small card. The P becomes the West Pico–East First Street motor-coach line, numbered 26. The R becomes the Whittier Boulevard–West Third Street line, numbered 28. The S gives way to the San Pedro–West Seventh Street line, numbered 29. A rider’s alphabet is being exchanged for a set of figures.
That is a small municipal event of a sort easily lost beneath larger proclamations. People remember how they got to a job long after the timetable that explained the journey has been discarded. A route letter can be part of the working vocabulary of a household, passed to a child with instructions about where to get off.
The authority is entitled to make a case for new equipment and for the flexibility of buses. It is also obliged to show what that flexibility accomplishes. The ability to leave a rail does not automatically put a vehicle where a passenger needs it, when the passenger needs it.
For that reason, the Herald believes the conversion must be judged by a public record of service. Published schedules, understandable signs, dependable transfers and attention to the hours outside the downtown rush deserve more weight than a ceremonial display of the fleet. Residents should be able to compare the trip they had with the trip they are now offered.
Los Angeles is often discussed as though every person has a motorcar waiting at the curb. Municipal policy cannot honestly proceed on that assumption. The person carrying purchases, the young worker and the older resident have claims on the streets that do not disappear because their transport is less fashionable.
Nor does the retirement of a rail line settle the larger use of public space. Buses also require room to move, places to stop and crossings that permit passengers to reach them. A policy that acquires new vehicles while neglecting their passage through traffic has purchased only part of a service.
The rail’s last day will receive its place in the scrapbook. The next ordinary Tuesday is the fairer examination. When the rider who once asked for the P must now ask for the 26, the city owes more than a correct answer about the number. It owes a usable journey.
Sources & further reading
Related Herald reporting
- For the New Blue Line, Pico Is Still the End of the Downtown Journey — David Ridley, 1990-09-09.
- Expo Reaches the Beach Along a Corridor Los Angeles Nearly Forgot — Andrew Chenoweth, 2016-05-21.
- Last Red Car Runs to Long Beach; Buses Take the Route — Thomas McKenna, 1961-04-10.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation