The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
A New Cecil Series Returns Attention to Separate Deaths, Not a Single Mystery
A four-part documentary renews interest in Elisa Lam and a hotel history often compressed into an unreliable number.
LOS ANGELES, Feb. 11.—Netflix’s new four-part Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel returns attention to Elisa Lam’s 2013 death and the Main Street hotel’s earlier history. The cases require separate explanations. A frequently repeated total of sixteen deaths is not a coroner’s finding that sixteen murders, or sixteen unsolved cases, occurred there.
A chronology includes these earlier names and years: Percy Cook, 1927; W. K. Norton, 1931; Benjamin Dodich, 1932; Louis Borden, 1934; Grace Magro, 1937; Roy Thompson, 1938; Erwin Neblett, 1939; Dorothy Seger, 1940; an infant in the Purcell case, 1944; Robert Smith, 1947; Helen Gurnee, 1954; Julia Moore, 1962; Pauline Otton and pedestrian George Gianinni, 1962; Goldie Osgood, 1964; unidentified people in 1975 and 1992; Lam, 2013; and a man in 2015.
These entries mix reported suicides, accidents, homicide and unresolved circumstances. Osgood’s murder remained unsolved after a suspect was cleared. Lam’s completed medical classification was accidental drowning. The numerical shorthand conceals those differences.
The record also includes natural deaths and additional reported incidents, so any count depends on what is included. John Leake’s 2007 account associates the Cecil with Jack Unterweger’s 1991 stay. That lodging connection should be distinguished from deaths within the building. The hotel’s connection with Richard Ramirez requires the same care.
Sources & further reading
- Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel — Imagine Entertainment / Imagine Documentaries; February 10, 2021 release; undated production page.
- List of violent incidents at the Cecil Hotel — Wikipedia contributors; referenced newspaper and coroner records; Later reference chronology.
- Elisa Lam: completed medical findings — County of Los Angeles Department of Coroner; 2013.
- The Vienna strangler — John Leake / The Guardian; November 10, 2007.
Related Herald reporting
- Death at the Cecil Recalls Two Earlier Hotel Cases — Beatrice Lyle, 1932-09-19.
- Coroner’s Jury Calls for Homicide Proceedings in Hotel Infant’s Death — Frank Delaney, 1944-09-09.
- Woman’s Fall From Cecil Window Kills a Man on the Street — James Corbett, 1962-10-14.
- Pershing Square’s Bird Feeder Found Slain at the Cecil — James Corbett, 1964-06-06.
- Cecil Stay Emerges in the Search for Ramirez’s Movements — James Corbett, 1985-09-08.
- Unterweger Verdict and Death Leave Los Angeles Cases in an International Record — Lisa Sheffield, 1994-06-30.
- Police Seek Public Help Finding Canadian Visitor Elisa Lam — Jennifer Palmer, 2013-02-06.
- Coroner Rules Elisa Lam’s Death an Accidental Drowning — Melissa Warren, 2013-06-21.
- The Cecil Reopens With 600 Rooms Intended for Low-Income Residents — Alexander Fletcher, 2021-12-15.
- Cecil Ground Lease Offered for Sale After Housing Conversion — Alexander Fletcher, 2024-03-12.
- City Council Adds the Cecil Hotel to Its Landmark Record — Heather Maldonado, 2017-03-02.
- Missing Visitor’s Body Found in Cecil Rooftop Water Tank — Alexander Fletcher, 2013-02-20.
HERALD ORIGINAL



Join the conversation