The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Woman’s Fall From Cecil Window Kills a Man on the Street
Police distinguish the woman who came from an upper floor from the pedestrian struck below.
LOS ANGELES, Oct. 14.—Two people were killed Friday night when a woman came down from a ninth-floor window of the Cecil Hotel and struck a man on the sidewalk. Police identified them as Pauline Otton, twenty-seven, and George Gianinni, sixty-five.
Officers first considered whether the two had come from the building together. The account published Saturday instead describes Gianinni as a pedestrian struck by the falling woman. Nothing in that account establishes a joint agreement between them.
Otton had been at the hotel with her estranged husband. Police described the immediate movement from the room as a leap or fall. That wording leaves a question that should not be settled by the unusual fact that another person was killed below.
The deaths share one impact but different circumstances. The investigation must account for the woman’s departure from the window and the man’s position on the street separately.
Sources & further reading
- Woman’s Death Leap Kills Man on Street — Los Angeles Times, reproduced by Craig Owens; October 13, 1962; later archival transcription.
- Horror at the Cecil Hotel: Suicidal woman jumps to death from ninth floor and lands on passer-by — James Wray / Daily Crime; October 30, 2017 retrospective; reproduces original newspaper clipping.
Related Herald reporting
- Pershing Square’s Bird Feeder Found Slain at the Cecil — James Corbett, 1964-06-06.
- Coroner’s Jury Calls for Homicide Proceedings in Hotel Infant’s Death — Frank Delaney, 1944-09-09.
- Cecil Stay Emerges in the Search for Ramirez’s Movements — James Corbett, 1985-09-08.
- Death at the Cecil Recalls Two Earlier Hotel Cases — Beatrice Lyle, 1932-09-19.
- Unterweger Verdict and Death Leave Los Angeles Cases in an International Record — Lisa Sheffield, 1994-06-30.
- Police Seek Public Help Finding Canadian Visitor Elisa Lam — Jennifer Palmer, 2013-02-06.
- Missing Visitor’s Body Found in Cecil Rooftop Water Tank — Alexander Fletcher, 2013-02-20.
- Coroner Rules Elisa Lam’s Death an Accidental Drowning — Melissa Warren, 2013-06-21.
- City Council Adds the Cecil Hotel to Its Landmark Record — Heather Maldonado, 2017-03-02.
- A New Cecil Series Returns Attention to Separate Deaths, Not a Single Mystery — Jennifer Palmer, 2021-02-11.
- The Cecil Reopens With 600 Rooms Intended for Low-Income Residents — Alexander Fletcher, 2021-12-15.
- Cecil Ground Lease Offered for Sale After Housing Conversion — Alexander Fletcher, 2024-03-12.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation