The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Supreme Court sustains Japanese American curfew convictions; Yasui case returned for sentence
The justices uphold the wartime curfew while returning Minoru Yasui’s case to the lower court over its citizenship findings and sentence.
The Supreme Court yesterday sustained the wartime curfew imposed on persons of Japanese ancestry in the West Coast military area. Its decisions in the cases of Gordon Hirabayashi and Minoru Yasui leave American citizenship no defense against that particular restriction, though the Court directed further proceedings on Yasui’s sentence.
Chief Justice Stone wrote the opinions. In Hirabayashi’s case the justices accepted the curfew as an exercise of the combined war powers of Congress and the Executive. The Court treated the emergency as sufficient to permit a restriction that distinguished people by ancestry. That is the Court’s judgment concerning the challenged curfew; it is not a criminal finding that Hirabayashi committed espionage or sabotage.
Hirabayashi, born in Seattle and a University of Washington student, had been convicted of both failing to report for removal and violating the requirement to remain at his residence between 8 p.m. and 6 a.m. He received concurrent three-month sentences. Because the curfew conviction was upheld, the Court found it unnecessary to decide the separate reporting count. The decision therefore leaves that question outside its holding.
Yasui, an Oregon-born lawyer who held a commission in the Army Reserve, deliberately sought arrest in Portland to test the curfew. The lower court had ruled the restriction invalid for citizens, but had then treated his previous conduct, including work for the Japanese consulate, as a loss of citizenship. The Government did not defend that conclusion before the Supreme Court.
The justices sustained Yasui’s conviction under the same reasoning applied to Hirabayashi. They nevertheless vacated the judgment and sent the case back for resentencing and an opportunity to strike the findings that he had lost his citizenship. His one-year term was the maximum permitted by the statute and had followed those findings. The Government, the opinion states, does not dispute his citizenship.
The two outcomes require a careful distinction. Hirabayashi’s concurrent sentences stand on the curfew count. Yasui’s conviction is sustained, but the judgment and sentence must be reconsidered below. Neither opinion decides every question raised by the removal and continued confinement of families. The constitutional controversy over the larger program cannot be compressed into a ruling that the justices did not make.
Sources & further reading
- Hirabayashi v. United States, 320 U.S. 81 — Supreme Court of the United States; opinion of Chief Justice Harlan Fiske Stone (1943-06-21).
- Yasui v. United States, 320 U.S. 115 — Supreme Court of the United States; opinion of Chief Justice Harlan Fiske Stone (1943-06-21).
Related Herald reporting
- Roosevelt gives military broad authority to exclude civilians from designated areas — Samuel Voss, 1942-02-25.
- Manzanar’s first newspaper reports 3,302 people as removal reshapes family life — William Keane, 1942-04-12.
- Tule Lake segregation policy sends families into another round of removal — William Keane, 1943-10-16.
- Jerome closes, but transfers carry its families to other camps — William Keane, 1944-07-01.
- Court upholds exclusion conviction but bars detention of a citizen conceded loyal — Samuel Voss, 1944-12-19.
- Manzanar closes as former residents face the difficult work of return — William Keane, 1945-11-22.
- War Relocation Authority ends; its records and unfinished affairs pass to Interior — William Keane, 1946-12-31.
- New federal law opens property-loss claims for Japanese American evacuation — Samuel Voss, 1948-07-03.
- Federal commission urges apology and $20,000 payments for wartime incarceration — Joan Mercer, 1983-06-17.
- Judge’s written opinion identifies withheld evidence behind Korematsu conviction — Joan Mercer, 1984-04-20.
- Reagan signs apology and $20,000 redress law for Japanese American survivors — Richard Hale, 1988-08-11.
- First redress checks reach nine survivors, including a 107-year-old Angeleno — Richard Hale, 1990-10-12.
- New redress rule includes some wartime-born children excluded from the family home — Stephen Evers, 1997-05-28.
- Psychology review traces incarceration’s effects through family silence and later generations — Eric Bennett, 2019-02-01.
- California Assembly apologizes for its role in Japanese American incarceration — Amanda Rhodes, 2020-02-21.
- Book of incarceration names begins national journey, with Manzanar visit planned — Amanda Rhodes, 2025-02-22.
- Manzanar children’s home study puts survivor and descendant voices into preservation plans — Amanda Rhodes, 2026-10-01.
- Supreme Court Rules School Segregation Unconstitutional — Mary Ellison, 1954-05-18.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation