The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Tule Lake segregation policy sends families into another round of removal
A federal classification system based on registration and leave clearance is reorganizing the camp population, with relatives caught in the same transfers.
The War Relocation Authority’s segregation program is producing a second movement of families, this time between the camps. Tule Lake in northern California has been selected to receive people whom the agency classifies as unsuitable for its leave program, while other residents are being moved out to make room.
The classifications follow this year’s registration, including questions about military service and allegiance. Refusal to answer, a negative answer and a qualified answer have carried serious consequences. The questions did not confront every person in the same legal position. American-born citizens were asked to disavow an allegiance to Japan they might never have held; Japanese immigrants remained barred from American naturalization.
President Roosevelt told the Senate on September 14 that the first segregation trains had begun moving earlier that month. He described the great majority of people removed from the coast as loyal to American democratic institutions. His message promised an appeals procedure to correct classification mistakes, while stating that people segregated at Tule Lake would not be eligible to leave while the war or military requirements continued.
The Government’s description of a person as disloyal must be distinguished from proof of an individual offense. The program also moves relatives who accompany a person selected for segregation. A family’s presence at Tule Lake cannot by itself establish what each member answered, believed or did. Children and dependent relatives are affected by the disposition of adults’ cases.
A public letter issued at Jerome on August 6 told residents that Tule Lake had been selected and that its population would not be eligible for leave. The letter presented segregation as a means of advancing the resettlement of other residents outside the exclusion area. It also asserted that the new arrangement was not intended as punishment. That assurance is the agency’s position; the restriction on departure is a practical consequence for those transferred.
The distinction between leave and unrestricted return remains essential. Permission to leave another camp for an approved destination does not end the military exclusion from the West Coast. A family willing to establish itself elsewhere may face a different prospect from one trying to return to the home or livelihood from which it was removed.
Transfers during September and October are remaking communities established only last year. Officials are treating classification and transport as administrative work, but the same decisions govern whether relatives remain together and whether another journey ends in a place with any prospect of departure. No general label adequately describes all the people whose lives are being rearranged by this policy.
Sources & further reading
- Message to the Senate on the Segregation Program of the War Relocation Authority — President Franklin D. Roosevelt; original public message and Senate Document 96 (1943-09-14).
- Open Letter to All Residents of the Center — War Relocation Authority, Jerome Relocation Center; Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley (1943-08-06).
- Tule Lake Segregation Center Pamphlet — National Park Service, Tule Lake National Monument.
- Records of the War Relocation Authority: community-analysis records, 1942–1946 — National Archives; original War Relocation Authority records.
Related Herald reporting
- Manzanar’s first newspaper reports 3,302 people as removal reshapes family life — William Keane, 1942-04-12.
- Supreme Court sustains Japanese American curfew convictions; Yasui case returned for sentence — Samuel Voss, 1943-06-22.
- Jerome closes, but transfers carry its families to other camps — William Keane, 1944-07-01.
- Court upholds exclusion conviction but bars detention of a citizen conceded loyal — Samuel Voss, 1944-12-19.
- Roosevelt gives military broad authority to exclude civilians from designated areas — Samuel Voss, 1942-02-25.
- Manzanar closes as former residents face the difficult work of return — William Keane, 1945-11-22.
- War Relocation Authority ends; its records and unfinished affairs pass to Interior — William Keane, 1946-12-31.
- New federal law opens property-loss claims for Japanese American evacuation — Samuel Voss, 1948-07-03.
- Federal commission urges apology and $20,000 payments for wartime incarceration — Joan Mercer, 1983-06-17.
- Judge’s written opinion identifies withheld evidence behind Korematsu conviction — Joan Mercer, 1984-04-20.
- Reagan signs apology and $20,000 redress law for Japanese American survivors — Richard Hale, 1988-08-11.
- First redress checks reach nine survivors, including a 107-year-old Angeleno — Richard Hale, 1990-10-12.
- New redress rule includes some wartime-born children excluded from the family home — Stephen Evers, 1997-05-28.
- Psychology review traces incarceration’s effects through family silence and later generations — Eric Bennett, 2019-02-01.
- California Assembly apologizes for its role in Japanese American incarceration — Amanda Rhodes, 2020-02-21.
- Book of incarceration names begins national journey, with Manzanar visit planned — Amanda Rhodes, 2025-02-22.
- Manzanar children’s home study puts survivor and descendant voices into preservation plans — Amanda Rhodes, 2026-10-01.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation